Everyday, I face the awful decision of Blog vs Book. I let my husband taste something and after finding out if it is good, I ask “Save?” or “Post?” It is so frustrating having to chose! This Tomatoless Meat Sauce is one of those recipes that is so special that it probably should be saved for the book, but you, my lovely readers, have taken precedence with this one.
I learned early on that too many tomatoes can really affect my stomach. It leaves me hanging out near the bathroom for the better part of the day. I have been in denial for the past few years about this and continue to eat them. There's been so much hype lately about the Paleo Autoimmune Protocol and nightshades (tomatoes, peppers, potatoes, eggplant) being detrimental for those of us with autoimmune diseases; so I just can't possibly keep this sauce to myself for the next 9 months. You can serve it over Zucchini Noodles or use it in my Lasagna Recipe. This recipe will probably end up on the book as well. But still purchase it, as it will contain many more recipes!
My Italian Grandmother taught me two things – pork and red wine belong with a meat sauce! Although, there's quite the debate amongst my family members whether wine belongs in a glass for the chef or in the sauce. I personally do a little of both! I will be including my Great-Grandmother's original meat sauce recipe in my book, so stay tuned for that one. It's the best sauce you'll ever taste and has been perfected over many generations.
I chose to make a bolognese style sauce for this tomatoless meat sauce. I am partial to it because of the complicated flavor profiles that come out with the use of chopped vegetables, salty pork, and a touch of red wine. A traditional bolognese sauce uses a little cream at the end to reduce the acidity of the tomatoes, but since this sauce is sans tomato, we don't need it. I actually throw in a little apple cider vinegar to add a little zing that you would miss otherwise.
*I can't remember where I first saw the notion of using beets to make a sauce instead of tomatoes, but I've been wanting to make one for the past couple of years. Whoever the original creator was is a genius, but this sauce is like no other that I saw when searching the internet for recipes. I think you're going to love it! Oh and I hate beets. FYI.
Shared on Allergy Free Wednesdays
Monifah
Wow!!!!!!!!!!!!! MUST.TRY.TONIGHT. Thank you..
Loretta
Yay! I’m so excited! I’m pinning this right away and will serve it over my spaghetti squash. I don’t have a spiralizer, but that’s at the top of my list. Thanks for the amazing recipe and have a great weekend!
Monifah
What to replace the red wine with btw??
Against All Grain
there’s a lot of non alcoholic wines out there that would probably work. Otherwise I saw a few things when I googled it about using red wine vinegar and some grape juice. You may also be able to just use more stock (I’d recommend beef if you’re doing all stock no wine) but the flavors will quite different. You may just need to play around with the salt and vinegar towards the end. You can also try this one from The Urban Poser! There’s no wine in it. https://urbanposer.blogspot.com/2011/04/fauxmato-marinara-sauce.html
Monifah
I replaced it with a splash of red wine vinegar and some more stock, Tasted really good! Thanks so much 🙂
Sandy Gillett
Thank You for posting this and I’ll still buy the book. In fact, I can’t wait. I’d pre-order right now if that was possible. Congratulations and blessings to you these next nine months!
Lauren
Hmm. A fellow paleo of Italian (Mediterranean) descent. Have you noticed this trend?
Alisa Boboltz
Yum, I love the idea of the bacon in there, in addition to all the veggies. I think this is the most beautiful, bright red sauce I’ve ever seen. I’ll have to try making it one of these days!
Corinne
Tomatoes don’t bother me, but I would love to try this recipe. It sounds delicious! What are the noodles in the pictures?
I am a new subscriber and I want you to know how much I appreciate your hard work and willingness to share your recipes. Thank you! I look forward to your book.
Emily
THANK YOU for this nightshade-free sauce recipe! I am like you…I love tomatoes but they don’t love me back and I’ve been in denial about it too, despite my overall good nutrition with the GAPS diet for autoimmune disease. I am fine with omitting potatoes, peppers and eggplant, but tomatoes are tough, especially this time of year when they are in season. Can’t wait to give this a try!
Saundra
So happy for this sauce since I avoid nightshade plants. It is so hard to cook without tomatoes! I plan to try this this week. Thanks so much for sharing.
Kimberly
I have suspected that tomatoes are one of my culprits for a while (I dont usually get that stick…but i certainly dont feel well if i eat too many). But wasn’t sure if it made sense guess it does!
This looks great – cant wait to try it.
Salla
Hey! Thank you about your fantastic recipes. They have helped me a lot. 🙂 I would like to know what you eat during a day, so could you post your one day food diary? Would it be too much a trouble? 🙂 But anyway, thank you about your recipes!
–salla
Julie
I am celiac and tomatoes can have a reaction for me just like gluten. I am so excited to try this but I will be using ground turkey.
Amy Pulley
Thank you for this!!! One of my kids is sensitive to tomatoes (which sucks because he LOVES them). I’m so excited to try this – we’ve just avoided tomato dishes, but this may open up a few more dinner options.
Alissa
This is brilliant and beautiful. I’m always amazed at your recipes. I just bought two bundles of beets at the market this weekend. Beet sauce here I come!
Pepella
This recipe is excellent! I made it today for supper, and my four kids (ages 1-6) all loved it, and went for seconds, thirds and fourths! I don’t think they have ever eaten that much. If all your recipes in your coming cookbook is this delicious, I won’t hesitate a second to buy or not. Thanks for sharing!
Sabrina
This looks sooooo yummy! My son and I have sensitivities with tomatoes. This really is a bummer since my family make our own tomato sauce- we’re Italian. I have beets in the garden and can’t wait to try this out! I found you through Heather at Allergy friendly. Thanks a bunch.
Julie
I tried this recipe last night. Love it. Tomatoes and garlic used to tear me up before I got my celiac under control but tomatoes still bother me even now. I used ground turkey instead of sausage. I also added sautéed mushrooms. I think next time I might use my food mill like when I used to make regular tomatoes sauce from scratch. It was a bit grainy for me but I did get inpatient with my blender.
Great recipe!
Draven
Oh. My. Goodness.
This recipe is a godsend! (found you through ‘simply sugar and GF’ recipe exchange) I’ve been on a nightshade-free diet for about 3 years since discovering, even after being on a GF diet for my Celiacs, that tomatoes and potatoes did not agree with me. I can’t tell you how much I’ve missed spaghetti and lasagna and all those wonderful comfort foods. THANK YOU FOR SHARING THIS!
Julie
I had some beets left over from when I made this recipe. I peeled two large beets and this recipe only needed one. Today I sliced the leftover beets about a 1/4″ thick and steamed then with califlower. They taste great together.
Liz P
Whoa! This sauce is AHmazing! Eating a bowl of it right now! Being on the AI protocol, and tomato free for over a year, I cannot tell you how happy this makes me. I will buy three of your books for sharing this. So GOOD!
carla
I made it without the wine and substituted it with a little red wine vinegar and a splash of grape juice. I thought the sauce was great and I’m making it a double batch to freeze. My son loves it on spaghetti squash and is following the paleo autoimmune protocol. Thanks for this awesome recipe!!!
Against All Grain
So great to hear!
Andrea
Thank-you SOOOOOO much for posthing this!!!! I love cooking, but am frustrated having to relearn how I do everything, and red sauce was something I was mourning.
Allison
Does anyone know if this sauce freezes and defrosts ok? Thanks!
Liz
Made this for Christmas Eve for myself and put it over zucchini noodles. Added a zucchini and yellow squash to the sauce as well, and used 1# of beef and .5# of pork sausage. I used to think I hated beets. This recipe proved me wrong.
My family (the ones that roll their eyes at when I complain about grain-fed meats, let alone the vegetables fermenting on the counter) had it for leftovers not once but twice (I made sure to wait till they’d finished the first meal to tell them it was tomato-less) and I’ve been asked to send along the recipe. Success!
Gail B
I made this last week and it was surprisingly good! I’ve only been Paleo for 2 weeks and because of Hashi thyroid, am on the autoimmune Paleo. Unfortunately after eating my second day of this sauce, I find I can’t eat beats 🙁 I also found that beats are in the night shade family which is on the no-no list. However, I did have a couple of co-workers try it and they also thought that it was better than they thought it would be.
Against All Grain
Beets are not nightshades but I’m sorry you cannot tolerate them, that’s. bummer!
Stephanie
WOW! I just took my first taste and this is so wonderful! I’m hoping my kids don’t notice since I’m using it on my first ever meatza.
Alexandra Prosser
I have an autoimmune disease (Sjogren’s) and recently saw a nutritionist (Functional Medicine) who recommended I follow the Paleo diet, so no tomatoes!! I chanced upon your website searching the Pininterest site and I am so glad I did. When I saw this recipe I actually wanted to cry!! Being new to Paleo I felt the best way to transition was to find recipes similar to those I am used to cooking, but with ingredient substitutions, and this recipe fits the bill perfectly. Thank you!
Leila
Amazing recipe… Thanks so much for sharing! X
Kiah
YESSS!!!! Unbelievable. Just yesterday – for real – I finally gave in to the fact that I can’t eat red sauce (or any form of concentrated cooked tomatoes)… and I can’t believe that you hate beets but still love this because that’s the one veggie I totally despise. So thank you thank you thank you! Can’t wait to try this.
Jayne Yeates
OMG I made this today – I did toy around with the herbs but the end result was something sensational – looking at the end result it’s almost like a “trompe l’oeil”of a “normal” bolognaise sauce. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe
Kerri
Can you taste the beets strongly in this recipe? I don’t like beets at all. I HATE them to put it lightly. But would love to try this!
Against All Grain
The beets are really more for color but add a touch of sweetness. You could try using 1 and then a second if you think you can handle the taste.
Dawn @TransformedByFood.com
Can’t wait to try this! I found your recipe through the Nightshade-Free Nutrition Guide, and have linked to it is an alternative to my tomato based Bolognese sauce recipe. Mine doesn’t have any dairy or wine in it, though.
Thanks for sharing your creative culinary spirit with us!
Cindy
I made this tonight and OMG!!!! It was absolutely awesome!!!! Thank you for sharing this with us. Now, I need to perfect my zucchini noodles to equal the awesomeness of this sauce. 🙂
Holly Peterson
Wow! I”m allergic to tomatoes and haven’t had red sauce in about 10 years! This sauce is perfect and the lasagna was amazing too! Thank you!!!
Cheryl
I”m allergic to tomatoes and carrots both. Anyone have suggestions on subbing out the carrots?
Mc
Pumpkin puree or sweet potatoes could be a substitute for the carrots
Annie
Hi Danielle, thank you so much for creating this. I had hoped to meet you and get my book signed when you were at Tyler Florence’s in Mill Valley recently but had a last minute conflict. 🙁
After several months on paleo we’ve discovered that tomatoes were the cause of my celiac husband’s long standing hand aches. I’m excited this allows us to put spaghetti back on the menu.
Here’s my question: if I wanted to create a ‘base’ tomato-less sauce for Indian and other non-Italian dishes, etc, would I simply leave out the bacon, wine, basil, oregano, thyme (and of course the beef)? Has anyone tried this?
David
I’ve used a minimal version of this (carrots, beets, tamarind or umeboshi paste) as a base for tomato-based curry dishes. It works okay but I’d love to hear ways to improve upon it for that purpose.
GypsyGina
Hi David, When I was macrobiotic about 10 years ago, that is the exact same sauce I used to use. I made a lasagna with it and my Italian mother did not know there wasn’t any tomatoes in it! It was awesome 🙂
cayce
I’m super excited to see this since I recently found out that I am extremely allergic to my beloved buddy the tomato. Being that my family has many food allergies gluten topping the list. I have a q. Due to food allergies carrots as well as wine and basil are a no no in my house and so are sweet potatoes those are the main ingredients that keep popping up in every single tomatoless sauce recipe I find online. Do you have any suggestions for subs for this recipe that you think will still make it taste amazing or another recipe all together? I miss miss miss sauce and I know my family does as well so if anyone else has great recipes for tomatoless anything ie. Ketchup bbq sauce etc I’d love yall forever lol ty
Mc
I’ve seen some recipes that use pureed pumpkin instead of carrots or sweet potatoes. Substitutes for basil could be other Italian herbs such as oregano, thyme, marjoram. Ideas for substituting for wine: Chicken, beef, or vegetable stock, grape, pomegranate, or cranberry juice, etc. For acidity add about a tablespoon of red wine vinegar or balsamic vinegar per cup of stock or fruit juice.
Ivy
Does anyone have any tips for prepping the beets? I tried peeling and dicing them raw and stopped and decided to roast them so the skins slip off.
David
Not sure if this tip helps, but I didn’t like red stains everywhere so I started buying the prepared (steamed?) ginger beets in the Whole Foods Market salad bar.
Brittany Bach
Danielle, thank you so much for this! I haven’t had a red sauce in over two years since cutting out tomatoes due to having MS and I can’t even tell you how much I enjoyed our meal with this sauce. We had it served over spaghetti squash. So delicious! Even my Italian husband who was raised on incredible food approved of this. This recipe is so well done!
Chris McCollough
Danielle, thank you. This is fabulous! I make a big batch and freeze it in portions. I have also used it on a grain-free pizza crust. Now I have Italian food back on my meal plans. I will begin to play with the spices to find a substitute for salsa. Any Ideas? I just ordered a crepe maker – thanks to your grain-free tortilla recipe. If I get Mexican back on it too I will be in heaven. Thank you again!
Danielle
I have a pico de gallo recipe as well as many different Mexican dishes on the blog. https://againstallgrain.com/2012/04/30/paleo-taco-sauces/
Danielle B.
Thank you sooooo much! This is the first recipe I have tried from your site–actually the first no-nightshade recipe I have looked up and it was delicious. Even my family that is not on any kind of diet loved it. I will definitely be looking at your site for more recipes in the future.
Shannon Klein
I have made this three times now. The times I follow the recipe exactly it comes out the best. I didn’t have any bacon once and it was not quite as good. Another time I didn’t do the finial cook once it goes back into the pan for the entire time and it had me up with gas all night from the undercooked vegetables… I won’t do that again. Even so it makes me SO HAPPY to have such a delicious tomato substitute. This recipe alone has convinced me that I can stick to the Autoimmune diet that my body so desperately needs. THANK YOU!! It also convinced me to purchase The Autoimmune Paleo Cookbook by Mickey Trescott. Thank you for that as well! There are so many more awesome ideas in there that make Autoimmune Paleo a lifestyle worth living and not just a confinement to survive. I can not wait until Sarah Ballantyne’s Paleo Approach Cookbook is available in August! I am so hooked… and it’s all because you posted this recipe and I realized I can live this way after all!
Shannon Klein
Oh yeah and my DH who really dug his heels in when we first started cleaning up our diet actually said it was really good! “Like I am not just saying it to be nice, it is really good!” LOL!
Breanna Hendricks
This was hands-down the best meat sauce I have ever eaten by far!! Perfect recipe for everyday meals or special occasions 🙂 I have missed eating meat sauce bc of nightshade sensitivities but thanks to u I no longer have to miss out! This was delicious! This recipe is a keeper 🙂 love your first cookbook and have already preordered meals made simple! Thank you Danielle!
Sassyfras
This was wonderful. Even my picky 6 year old didn’t realize this wasn’t tomato sauce and gobbled it up! Think I will make extra and try freezing it next time! Delicious!
Kathleen
Wow! I just made this meat sauce and I am blown away by how well it turned out! My fiancé has all kinds of digestive issues and we haven’t been able to figure out what the problem is yet, but he’s basically given up everything, so this meal was perfect! Thank you Danielle 🙂 Also I just ordered your cookbook so I can’t wait for it to arrive!
Risa
This was wonderful but way to fatty for me as I generally don’t eat red meat. I think next time I’ll use less bacon and either ground turkey or ground sirloin. Thanks for giving me back red sauce! I’ve missed it!
Katie
I used Organic nitrate free turkey bacon and ground turkey because my son and I have a hard time with fatty red meat too. It was amazing!!! We ate this two nights in a row and both times he cleared his plate with his second helping. He’s only 6 and going grain free is getting easier for him thanks to this recipe! Try poultry products! They taste amazing!
Jennifer
What other recipes are good for those with silent reflux? It’s been difficult to find recipes that have flavor.
Marge
This sauce is absolutely wonderful! Thank you Danielle for this recipe.
Candace Boroos
This is amazing! I was so nervous about making lasagna without tomatoes but this assuaged my fears. Thank you for creating this recipe for “I can no longer have nightshades bc I have some sort of AI” folks out here. Cheers, CB
Lisa Bentley
I made this sauce last night with only a few minor changes to seasonings and it was absolutely delicious. My son, who hates beets, took his first bite and said, “Oh my God! This is soooo good!” 😊
I have to say I was skeptical. In the same way that I’m skeptical when people tell me they’ve found a protein powder that doesn’t taste like chalk. I was expecting something that tasted good enough to eat but nothing like pasta sauce. I was pleasantly surprised.
I plan on incorporating peppers and mushrooms into the sauce after the blending process since I like sauces with a lot of chunky veggies.
Thank you for helping me to enjoy my first taste of pasta WITH SAUCE in over a year!
Christine
This was AMAZING! I used turkey bacon and ground turkey. I don’t care for turkey. My husband doesn’t like beats or celery. My daughter hates beats and carrots. We all loved this!! I used the Instant Pot to make a quick spaghetti squash and put this over it… I couldn’t believe how quickly it all came together.
Danielle
So glad you enjoyed it!!
Tanya
The first time I saw beets used in place of tomatoes in a sauce was in a macrobiotic cookbook…they called it “nomato” sauce. The old school macro diets also did not include nightshades.
Danielle
That’s so interesting! Thank you for sharing!