*Note : Some have had issues with the dough for this recipe. I am deleting the yogurt note as I know for certain that the bread works with the Farmer's Cheese (dry curd cottage cheese). A reader told me they subbed thick greek yogurt and had success, but I have never tried it myself. I have also made this stuffing recipe using Elana's Pantry's Paleo Bread, so if you'd like, you can sub that loaf instead.
I am trying to make all of my Thanksgiving recipes early so I can have them up for you in time to go grocery shopping before Thursday!
Here is my favorite Gluten Free Thanksgiving Stuffing recipe. I made it a few years back when I first started the Specific Carbohydrate Diet and fooled everyone at the table into thinking it was just a general gluten filled stuffing. Much to their surprise, they found out the bread was grain-free! I tweaked a few things this year and it just passed the taste test with my husband and in-laws, so it's a winner. I'll be serving it to 8 guests this year who generally eat a grain/gluten filled diet.
As I've mentioned before, the kind of almond flour you use really makes all the difference in the quality of your bread. Store bought brands like Bob's Redmill WON'T work. It yields an overly moist bread with a really grainy consistency. See my post All About Almond Flour for some tips.
Combine all bread ingredients (except for the flour and water) in a food processor and blend until smooth. Add the flour and water and pulse until dough is combined. Dough will be a very sticky consistency.
Grease a 9×9 pan and put a rectangular piece of parchment paper at the bottom. This will help the loaf come out easily. Spread a little more oil on top of the parchment piece.
Fold the dough into pan and even it out with a spatula.
Bake at 325° for about 35 minutes. Careful to not let the top burn.
While the bread is baking, saute the celery, onions, garlic, sausage, apples, herbs and mushrooms in 1 tablespoon olive oil for about 15 minutes. Add the vermouth and bring to a boil. Remove from heat while you wait for the loaf to bake and cool.
Once the bread has cooled, slice it in half lengthwise to make two thin loaves. Next, slice it into 1/2 inch strips and then across those cuts to make small cubes.
Coat with 5 tbsp melted butter. Place on a cookie sheet and toast in the oven for 30 minutes on 300° turning occasionally. The bread should come out golden brown and slightly dry.
Toss the bread crumbs with the sauteed mixture, eggs, salt and pepper, and turkey stock.
Transfer stuffing to a well buttered baking dish and sprinkle the additional 2 tablespoons of butter on top. Cover with foil, and bake at 350° for 35 minutes. Uncover and bake 15 minutes until top is golden.
Tip : make the bread and toast it a couple of days before and store the toasted cubes in a ziplock. You can also saute the mixture the night before Thanksgiving and then put it all together right before baking.
Gia
I think there might be ingredients missing in the list? The directions mention sausage and apples, but I don’t see those listed under “for the stuffing”…if you could let me know/or repost, that would be great! My family loves sausage in their stuffing and I love apples!
Against All Grain
Oh my you’re right! I don’t know how those got deleted. They are the most important parts! I revised and the list now includes sausage, apples, and cremini mushrooms.
Nicole Harris
Ummmm, I’ve tried this stuffing and still think about it a year later. This stuffing is better than the stuffing I ate growing up, and stuffing is my favorite part of the Thanksgiving meal!
Liz
I’m allergic to casein so can’t have farmer’s cheese or yogurt. Is there any possible substitute that I could use in the bread? Or do you have another recipe for bread that would work? Thanks!
Against All Grain
I’m pretty sure my new bread would be delicious in this recipe! I will be using it for this Thanksgiving. https://againstallgrain.com/2012/05/21/grain-free-white-bread-paleo-and-scd/
Liz
Thanks, that’s great!
beth
That is awesome I LOVE stuffing but I went gluten free not to long ago and I cant eat gluten free bread because the startches make my blood sugar sky rocket. If I replace the sausage with bacon I think it will be pretty close to what our family makes every year thank you!!!
Angela Jones
I am thinking about making this for Thanksgiving this year. I have one question about the dry vermouth. I am on SCD and can not have refined sugar. Vermouth is infused with both herbs and sugar. I believe it is illegal on SCD. Even dry vermouth has 5% sugar. Can it be left out or is it really necessary for the recipe? Can you just use a dry white wine?
Thanks
Against All Grain
Just leave it out! Thank you for bringing that up. I’ll add a note.
Angela Jones
Thanks.
Amy
Oh! Thank you, Danielle! I had the same question and was wondering if I could substitute chicken broth instead! Thanks for the note! 🙂
Melanie
Would goat cheese work?
Amy
Wondering the same thing…. 😉 My tummy can handle goat’s milk better than cow’s milk. 🙂
Against All Grain
It would be worth a try! The consistency/moisture content is pretty similar to goat cheese so it will probably work just fine.
dianne
Have you made that bread in a regular bread pan before? Is it tasty for just eating?
Against All Grain
I used to make it in a loaf pan but the larger pan was easier to cut the bread into cubes. It is super tasty for eating but it does get a little more oily due to the cheese. Have you seen my sandwich bread recipe? I would use it over this personally.
Audrey
I trying to make this currently and the dough is coming out liquid. I have triple checked the ingredients but the only difference is that I had to use Almond Flour/Meal not just Almond Flour. 🙁
Against All Grain
Sorry, only blanched skinless almond flour will work for this recipe.
Wendy
Same problem here, liquid bread dough, and I am using the Honeyville blanched almond flour.
Against All Grain
This is strange. It should be a very thick dough. Question – what form of dairy are you using? I always use the Farmer’s cheese (Dry curd cottage cheese) but a reader a couple of years ago told me it worked with the thick yogurt so I added that note. I’ve never done it myself. She used Greek Yogurt with no liquid.
Leah Marchand
I noticed you scratched out the greek yogurt in place of the cheese. I was just getting ready to make this, all ingredients on hand (except farmers cheese)!! I was going to use the greek yogurt instead when I noticed it was scratched out. I’m assuming this won’t work. Any advice at this point?
Against All Grain
Hi Leah- I put a note at the top of the page to explain this. A few readers have come back today and said their dough was really watery. I only make the bread with farmers cheese but have had others use a thick Greek yogurt with success so that is why I originally made that note in the ingredients. My advice is leave out the 1/4 cup of water at first and only add it if your dough looks thicker than mine in the photos. Otherwise you should be ok.
Audrey
I made it with Greek yogurt yesterday and got “soup” so I slowly added in some coconut flour till I got the right consistency and it worked! It’s baked a little longer but it’s good.
Against All Grain
Also – make sure to use blanched skinless almond flour, not almond meal
Claire
I made the bread with greek yogurt this Thanksgiving, no problems whatsoever and everyone LOVED the stuffing even my paleo shy hubby:)
Lisa Whitaker
The bread recipe works just fine with the full fatted Greek Yogurt. I just leave the extra water out of the recipe because the yogurt does have a bit more water, even dripped.
Gillian
I served this for Christmas dinner and it was fantastic!!! I used dripped yogurt and the bread turned out great as the dripped yogurt is very thick. I can see that yogurt that’s not dripped would not work. Anyway, thank you so much for this recipe, Danielle!
Julie Espinoza Melka
How many will this serve?
Anne K
Seems like it’s going into a 9×13. I’ve just finished making the 2 major components- bread & veggie/sausage mix- but haven’t actually assembled it yet. I’m debating whether to freeze components separately, then bake on Thursday, or just mix & bake it now, then freeze as a whole unit.
Amy
I made this stuffing for the first time last year and it was so good. It tasted just like the real thing. I made the bread ahead of time about two days then cooked the veggie sausage mix the morning of Thanksgiving. I assembled it all together the morning of. It just seemed to be “fresher” to me that way. This year though I’m freezing separately and assembling and baking on Thursday. I hope this helps you..not sure. I guess it depends on how much time you have.
Amy
I was wondering the same..I made this last year for myself only as I am the only Grain-free person in my family. But this year I’ll be baking/cooking for 10. II just read that it says in the post that she served it to 8 people, so I guess just adjust your recipe to that total.
Anne K
Have you made this ahead of time, frozen it, then thawed on Thanksgiving day? If so, how does it fare? Thank you!
Julie Espinoza Melka
Thanks, Amy! One more question, do we use the whole bread from recipe for the stuffing? I measured mine, and it was a bit more than six cups.
Abby
Quick question! Do you bake the stuffing if you’re going to stuff the turkey with it or do you skip that part and bake it in the turkey? Also, I used goat cheese and it came out amazing! Sampled a little and it reminds me of the biscuits at Red Lobster, although much better! 🙂
Danielle
Bake the stuffing outside of the turkey!
Autumn Halazon
I’ve made this the last two years and love it! This year someone is allergic to eggs. Any substitutions??! Thank you
Karen
I made my first Thanksgiving meal this year and this stuffing was a hit!! I did make my own gluten free bread due to food sensitivities but everything else was made according to this recipe. So good!!