Gluten Free Sugar Cookies (Paleo and SCD)
Danielle Walker - AgainstAllGrain.com
1 dozen medium sized cookies
American
Dessert
Ingredients:
Frosting
- 6 tablespoons coconut butter (also called coconut cream concentrate)
- ¼ cup raw cacao butter, chopped
- ¼ cup honey
- ¼ cup cold coconut milk
optional: food coloring (this brand is all natural or use 1 tablespoon finely ground freeze dried strawberries or raspberries – you may need to add extra liquid to achieve desired consistency if using the dried fruit)
Instructions:
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
- Combine the dough ingredients in a food processor and process until a smooth ball of dough forms, about 30 seconds. Alternatively, mix all of the ingredients in a stand mixer or by hand. The food processed dough will be ultra smooth and the most like a conventional sugar cookie.
- Flatten the ball of dough into a ½” thick disk and wrap in plastic wrap. Chill for 20 minutes.
- Roll the dough out between two sheets of parchment paper, keeping it to a ¼” thickness. Remove the top sheet and sprinkle the top of the dough with 1 teaspoon coconut flour, rubbing it in slightly with your fingers. Dip a cookie cutter in a little flour then cut your shapes, peeling away excess dough as you work. Gather the excess dough into a ball and re-roll it. If it starts to dry out or crack as you work with it the second or third time, lightly wet your hands before kneading the scraps to add a little moisture back into the dough.
- Bake the cookies on a tray lined with parchment paper for 8-10 minutes. Cool completely on a wire rack.
Frosting
- Warm the cacao butter and coconut butter over low heat until melted, but not boiling. Pour it into a bowl and whisk in the cold coconut milk and honey. Refrigerate for 20 minutes to set.
- Scrape the frosting into a blender or food processor and pulse a few times until the frosting is smooth and fluffy. Add any food coloring if desired or leave white.
- Pipe designs or spread frosting onto cooled cookies.
*For the glossy look that I achieved with the dark pink heart, I first piped a thin border around the outside of the cookie and placed it in the fridge to harden for 10 minutes. Then I melted a little bit of the frosting until it was liquid and poured a little inside the border. I tilted the cookie around until the frosting “flooded” the space and stopped at the border. The others are just spread with an offset spatula then piped with designs.
paleo, scd, gluten free, holiday, fall, winter, spring, scd, cookies, sugar cookies, Valentine's Day, almond flour, dairy free
Hi there! The photos of this recipe and content above are copyright protected.
Please do not use our photos without prior written permission. Please do not copy this recipe and share it on your own site. If you wish to tell people about this recipe, please provide a link back to the recipe here on my blog rather than copying the recipe. If you make significant changes to a recipe, you are welcome to rewrite it in your own unique words and provide a link back here for credit. Thank you!
Jil
Hi Danielle,
These look fantastic. I have 2 questions for you. The raw cacao butter – is that a purchasable item at like Whole Foods or Trader Joe’s or does it have to be ordered? I am not familiar with that product. Also, I have a coconut butter at my grocery for about $9 … it should just contain coconut, correct? I can’t wait to make these but don’t want to buy the wrong ingredients. And, let’s be honest here, I am in far too big of a rush to make them to wait for delivery 🙂 Thanks so much
Against All Grain
Hi Jill – I believe that Whole Foods sells the Artisana brand of Cacao butter. It keeps for a long time in the fridge so if you do end up ordering it online, don’t worry about the large amount. You’ll use it over time! Coconut butter should only be made from coconut. I like to buy the Let’s Do Organic Boxes or the Artisana Packets (both in my Amazon store) because they come in smaller portions.
Jil
Thank you. I will check at whole foods tomorrow after I drop the kids to school. Just out of curiosity, have you been having trouble finding the Let’s Do Organic Coconut Flour? I have the shreds and and the shelves seem to be empty of the flour. I tried my local Sprouts( which carries it usually) and Whole Foods- both were out of the flour. Found that strange. I appreciate your reply. I can’t wait to make these … Mmmmm.
Jessica
Hi Jill… About the raw cacao… isn’t that like chocolate? Do these have a chocolate frosting? If I didn’t want the chocolate flavor, could I substitute coconut oil?
Thanks!
Against All Grain
It’s raw cacao butter. Not chocolate. It’s the fat that’s extracted from the cacao bean, similar to how coconut oil is made from a coconut but definitely not interchangeable. There’s no chocolate flavor
Katy
I’ve made these a couple times, and the first time was very successful! Today, the dough turned out sticky and was hard to work with. Any idea what could have gone wrong?? I’d love to try again and figure out what to alter or how to know before I roll it out. Thank you!
Danielle
Hi! It’s hard for us to be able to identify what you did differently than the first time when it was very successful! It could be the use of different brands, a measurement slightly off, etc. Sorry, we can’t shed more light on this – we hope you continue to enjoy these recipes! – Team DW
Amanda Rodriguez
Just voted for you! I checked out the competition first, just to be sure I was being fair, and your photos are far superior (also, I like your recipes best, which doesn’t hurt)!
Meghan
You are brilliant! These looks so good (AND CUTE!!), I can’t wait to try to make them. 🙂
Stephanie
Agreed!! GENIUS!
Krystal
Thanks! I feel the same way. My b’day is the 16th. I feel like a boyfriend’s worst nightmare. Christmas, then Vday, then my birthday. It’s like celebration whiplash. Thanks for the recipe! Perfect!
Angela Jones
These look amazing. Can’t wait to try them. Do you use whole fat coconut milk or the Trader Joes Light coconut milk?
Thanks,
Against All Grain
Whole fat
Rochelle
Oh, those are adorable! It’s hard to believe they are grain free. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
Rachel
What is blanched almond flour?
Amy Thomas
Is there any reason to use parchment paper over waxed paper? I’ve seen it called for in the recipes where dough must be rolled out. But my grandmother used to bake on waxed paper. I, on the other hand, have tried neither! Is there a difference? Is one less sticky than another?
Heather
I just made these yummy goodies and used wax paper. Once the cookies had cooled and I was peeling them off the wax paper, the bottoms stuck a bit. That might be the reason to use parchment paper, and it’s thicker! Hope that helps!
Alta
Genius frosting. I have used coconut butter in frostings before, but the combo of cacao butter and coconut butter? How awesome.
Gillian
Gorgeous cookies! And a thick, white, SCD-compliant frosting?! It’s almost too good to be true! Thank you SO much! The frosting recipe will really come in handy. You’re brilliant! Happy Birthday and Valentine’s Day! 🙂
Larissa
Just voted for you for best photography, you deserve it! Thanks again for another great recipe, I’m going to be making these next week!
Rita@Wild bird seed
Lovely and colour full cookies. I am going to try this recipe for Valentine’s Day celebrations. Thumps up photography.
Rebecca Prange
These do look amazing and I’ve been wanting ‘sugar’ cookies lately. One concern is that the colourings used in the frosting contain glycerin and citric acid, both of which are typically derived from corn.
Against All Grain
The natural coloring that I listed in the recipe is all natural and only uses food such as beets and turmeric for coloring. You can also make your own or use the freeze dried strawberry idea I gave in the recipe.
Rebecca Prange
According to the ingredient list at the link provided the food coloring includes citric acid and glycerin. Is there a chance the link takes us to a different product?
Kelli
Thank you so for sharing the sugar cookie recipe!
I was really missing baking goodies to give as gifts. My unhealthy but amazing sugar cookie pops
are often requested treats. Now, thanks to you, I can give a scrumptious, beautiful gift and say it
REALLY is good for you!
Love, love your blog
Kelli
moriah
I just made these for my daughter’s birthday which is Valentine’s Day and they are DELISH! The kids were all eating them before I could make the frosting – which I wasn’t going to do until Wed in hopes they wouldn’t eat them. Thanks for another great recipe!! Lots of smiles in our house – along with happy bellies 🙂
emily
for the cold coconut milk – should we use the canned stuff or coconut milk in a carton? if from the can – do we use just the solids (as if making whipped “cream”) or include the liquid, too?
thanks!
Against All Grain
Canned coconut milk always! 🙂 And you can use the combined milk. It will be thickened from being cold
Karla
Do you have a list of where you purchase all of your ingredients? I am from Canada and probably need to order online which is fine. What brand fo cocnut milk do you use that is SCD legal and in a BPA free can?
Against All Grain
This link talks about a few of the ingredients I use, including coconut milk. https://againstallgrain.com/f-a-q/
Nicole
My dough looks really crumbly after refrigerating. Could it be because my coconut oil isn’t melted?
Danielle
It could be since coconut oil solidifies when cool.
K
Karla…this response is years after your question. I also live in Canada, and I purchase a lot of the products Danielle’s uses at Natura Market, an online market in Toronto. I hope you see this, or have discovered them already. https://naturamarket.ca/
Susannah H
Should these be stored at room temp or in the fridge? Do you know how long they keep? I’m planning to make some for my daughter to have at school during the class Valentine’s Day party and I’m trying to figure out how early I can make them. Thank you!
Against All Grain
I gave them all away the day I made them so I’m not entirely sure how long they will last but I would assume a few days in the fridge. I would frost them as late as possible though so they don’t get soggy
Heather
When making the icing, is it possible to use coconut “spread” instead of the coconut butter? This is what I already have, https://www.earthbalancenatural.com/product/organic-coconut-butter/.
Thanks!
Against All Grain
It may work but I can’t say. I stay away from lecithin and canola oil.
Anne D
Thank you for so many amazing recipes. I baked the cookies today for Valentine’s Day, but when It came to the frosting, my honey turned the cacao butter/coconut butter mixture a deep, amber color. Any tips that will help me get white frosting?
Against All Grain
It will be a tan color until you blend it and then should turn back to white. I use a raw honey that is much lighter in color though than the kinds in the bears.
Anne D
Thanks! I did use a local raw honey — and yes, the frosting did get lighter, but not like the white in your photos. Still — these were a big hit on Valentine’s Day! I experimented with making the frosting pink/red using a little beet juice in one batch and a little pomegranate juice in another. Both worked well. Thanks again for sharing your great recipes and for responding to comments.
Angela Jones
My icing came out runny. Not a fluffy icing at all. What did I do wrong? Too cacao butter and cocount cream maybe?
Against All Grain
Did you follow the recipe exactly? Try putting it in the fridge and see if it hardens.
Brandon Nolte
I just made these last night and I had to comment. They are fantastic. I ran out of coconut oil, so I used butter instead, and wow were they good. What I like most about the recipe is how simple it is! Thanks 🙂
Lara Carter
Hi, these cookies look totally fab and I can’t wait to try them. Quick question.. when you say coconut milk… do you mean the cans of coconut milk like in the asian cooking section of the grocery store (that you have to shake up really well) or the coconut milk in the refrigerated section (like soy and rice milk)?
Against All Grain
Always use the can. The coconut milk “beverage” in the fridge has tons of additives
Lara
thanks!!
GiGi Eats Celebrities
How adorable are these! Who ever you gave them to must have been so very happy 🙂
Amanda B
Can you please provide the details if we wanted to substitute coconut flour in place of almond flour?
Against All Grain
Coconut flour has very different properties than almond flour, so it wouldn’t really work.
TanyaV
Made these on Valentines Day and I plan on making bunny and egg shapes for Easter. Super easy and yummy recipe!
Emma R
I made this recipe as the crust for a fruit pizza and it turned out so well. I just rolled it out between parchment to probably 1/4″ and baked for 12 minutes. It was the perfect way to celebrate my birthday!xcxz
Against All Grain
Fun idea!
Cato
Awesome cookies! I just made them as Halloween cookies. The dough works much better than flour dough; It’s very forgiving. Taste and texture are great. I did have problems with the icing, but I didn’t have any cacao butter. I tried coconut butter, but the frosting broke. I’ll have to keep trying at it. I think I might have to hide them from my wife and kids, I heard something about cookies for breakfast.
Savannah
Will the frosting be hard at room temperature? Or will it stick to paper? I was thinking about stacking a few of these but I’m afraid the frosting will stick. Great cookies though! I almost didn’t have enough to frost!
Diana
Hi. I made these cookies this evening, and must have done something incorrectly. I tried to make cutouts, but the dough was too sticky and soft, even after refrigerating it and after adding the coconut flour. So, I rolled and flattened them into round cookies. They tasted very good. I also messed up the icing. Refrigerated it too long, and then mixed it, and it was thick, so I added some extra coconut milk which was a big mistake – crystallized, so I threw it out. I ended up using some vanilla icing I had on hand. I used almond flour out of the bin at Whole Foods, so perhaps it was too course for the cookies. Again, they tasted very good, so I will try again. Thanks.
Tina
I found almond flour but as much as I know all the health food stores in Canada, I’m pretty sure this brand is not available. So in case of emergencies is there any other brand you would recommend as a good enough substitute? Have you tried almond flour/meal from whole foods bulk section?
Against All Grain
You can read my FAQ page for substitution suggestions and a link to even more info about almond flour. https://againstallgrain.com/f-a-q/
K
Tina. I know this response is years late, but I am also in Canada and can purchase Wellbee’s almond flour via https://naturamarket.ca/. I hope you see this if you haven’t already discovered them.
Austyn
I would love to make these but can’t get cacao butter where I live. Is there a substitution I could make?
Mary
So I made these cookies today and they taste different from regular sugar cookies, but their still really good. I didn’t make the icing, because I didn’t have the rest of the ingredients. Can I make a different type of icing for these cookies? Like a confectioners’ sugar icing? Plus I made these for my mom to try since she is on a paleo diet from her doctor.
lindsey
I’m wanting to make these yummy looking cookies for my sister’s bachelorette party this weekend, but I’m wondering how the frosting will travel. Does it need to stay refrigerated?
Chrissy Louise
Does the frosting harden like the more… typical…. sugar cookie frosting?
Jennifer Filbert
These are turning out great. I love that they use honey, because I keep bees and we have plenty of honey. 🙂 I am also going to confess that I did not chill the dough. We just started rolling it out and cutting it, and they cookies still worked.
Rachel
Do you mix it with dough attachment or the normal blade in the food processor? Can’t wait to try these!! 🙂
Becky
These cookies are so close to regular sugar cookies that no one even not the difference. The taste and texture is so good. Thanks so much for sharing the recipe!
Natalie
We made these for Christmas cookies this year and they were so delicious! I was surprised they were so good given the no -traditional ingredients but we gave them to a GF neighbor and they loved them as well!
Lauren J
Have you refrigerated the dough overnight instead of just 20mins? If so, how long did it need to thaw next day in order to be workable? Wanting to prep my lesson plan ahead of time.