I'm excited to share this clean Paleo Ketchup recipe with you. When I used to eat french fries, prior to having to cut out white potatoes, I used to say that they were just the vessel in which to deliver ketchup to my body. I ate them more for that tangy and sweet sauce than for the potatoes themselves. When I participated in a Whole 30 recently, I really missed my beloved condiment on some of our meals like hamburgers or roasted breakfast sweet potatoes. So I set off to convert the ketchup recipe from my cookbook Against all Grain to use Whole 30 approved ingredients. It took me a few tries to get the right balance of sweetness, acidity, and spices, but I finally got it and we love it.
We use the Sir Kensington's squeeze ketchup most often around here, especially when I don't have time to make it or am in a pinch. Even the switch to that was a victory after buying the organic brands from Whole Foods that had twice the sugar. It is a much healthier alternative to most store-bought brands, but I had hoped to find one for him that didn't use refined sugars. He, like his mama, loves his ketchup though, so I was worried it wouldn't fly.
The other day, I nervously served him his grain-free chicken nuggets with a dollop of the new ketchup. I didn't say anything and just set it down in front of him and walked away. To my surprise, it flew right under his radar! So now that it has passed the test with a 5-year old, it is ready for you guys!
We use the whole 4 ounces of dates because he is so used to a sweeter ketchup right now, but you can really use anywhere from 2-4 ounces. Start with 2 and add more if you need to.
And for all of those asking, his lunch box is a PlanetBox. You can order one here. It is a hefty price tag, but after testing out quite a few when Asher first started kindergarten, we landed on this one. It has never leaked despite Asher throwing his backpack down at the playground or tossing it into the car. And I was originally worried about it's larger size since Asher is on the smaller side of kindergarteners, but my little guy doesn't mind the extra weight at all. I saw it is an investment, and plan to use it for many years to come!
For all of you asking, Medjool dates will also work in this recipe. That being said, they are sweeter and a little more soft and don't have as long of a shelf life. I also prefer the less gritty texture of Deglet, plus they're easier to find. If you're using Medjool make sure to use the weight measurement, not the number of dates as they differ in size.
*None of the brands mentioned in this post are paying me to promote them. We just truly love the products. I do, however, get a small commission for anything purchased through Amazon, at no additional cost to you. This commission is used to help run this blog and continue recipe development for you!
Lauren Homayoun
Could you use medjool dates instead?
Danielle
Medjool are sweeter and a little more soft and don’t have as long of a shelf life. I also prefer the less gritty texture of deglet plus they’re easier to find usually. If you’re using medjool make sure to use the weight measurement, not the number of dates.
Colleen
I just made this with medjool dates. It worked well. It was easy, delicious and I will make this recipe again. I haven’t had it with deglet noor dates to compare but I will not go looking for them because this worked!
This site (and her cookbook) have been wonderful. My now 13 year old son was diagnosed with Crohne’s Disease back in October 2015 and we continue to use diet and supplements as a way of healing. He has not been on any maintanance medicine. We are working with a GI doctor that has been very supportive of our approach and is monitoring my son’s progress with lab work being completed about every three months. So far so good!
Danielle
Thank you Colleen! I’m so sorry to hear of your sons disease but glad to hear you’re seeing progress! I hope he finds full healing.
JustAddWaterSilly
OMG, I love you! Now I have ketchup back. You rock Danielle!!!
Danielle
Thank you!
Heather Carley
Danielle, is there a reason you use Deglet Noor dates in your recipes instead of medjool dates?
Danielle
Medjool are sweeter and a little more soft and don’t have as long of a shelf life. I also prefer the less gritty texture of deglet plus they’re easier to find usually. If you’re using medjool make sure to use the weight measurement, not the number of dates.
Danielle
Medjool are sweeter and a little more soft and don’t have as long of a shelf life. I also prefer the less gritty texture of deglet plus they’re easier to find usually.
coombsa
Are these dried dates or fresh dates?
Danielle
I’ve used both before. Just make sure you soak them!
Sonia
I made this less than a week ago, and that first day it was AMAZING! Like SO good. But today it’s kind of bleh. No flavor and weird tasting. I followed the recipe perfectly. I don’t know what to do to save it:(
Danielle
Hi Sonia- That’s so odd! I haven’t heard of that happening. Perhaps you could add more dates to sweeten to your liking/add more spices?
Danielle
Delicious! So glad you liked it.
Danielle
Yes!
Elizabeth Ridgeway
Hi – thank you for this beautiful recipe! Do you have any recommendations on a substitution for white vinegar? My daughter has a severe corn allergy and I do not have a good substitution.
Danielle
You’re welcome! It may have been typo, but I always use white wine vinegar, not distilled white wine vinegar which is derived from corn of potatoes. So, you could either use white wine vinegar or apple cider vinegar!
Tamara
Can I use a substitute for dates? Fructose
Danielle
Yep! You may have to reduce it a bit longer though so it gets thick.
Linda
What did you use as a substitute Tamara, I also would rather not have the fructose.
Laura
What are your favorite freezer containers?
Danielle
I like to use glass tupperware or freezer bags.
Sisl
Have you ever tried to use the “hot soup” function of a high powered blender i.e. vitamin instead of cooking?
Danielle
No, I haven’t!
Teecy Christmas
I have a batch of your ketchup in my fridge right now. I was going to make some of your BBQ sauce for chicken but was wondering if I could start with the ketchup and add to it? I have your Celebrations and Meals Made Simple (love both!). From the Celebrations book BBQ sauce recipe- would I start with the coconut aminos and add the rest? Thanks for all you do! I love following you and I have told so many people about you- everything I’ve made of yours turns out great!
Danielle
Hi Teecy,
That would work! You could skip adding the additional allspice and garlic as well.
Anne O'Leary
Love, LOVE this ketchup. If I make my own ketchup, mayo and yoghurt, it’s hard to make a bad meal after that. This is my go-to ketchup recipe – great with homemade burgers, BBQ chicken fillets, cheese, sweet potato fries…and I use it as a seasoning in my meatball mix too. Yummy!
Danielle
So glad you loved it, Anne!
Cheryl Macdonald
This ketchup is AH-mazing! We whipped it up in a pinch, because going to the store is a hassle these days, and didn’t have time to boil and simmer, but it turned out so delicious. Myy 4 year old loved it! He was not disappointed. I’m not sure who enjoyed it more, him or us?
This is our go-to from now on!