I know you guys are always looking for easy weeknight meals with minimal ingredients, so Jenny is back to share this Baked Garlic Mushroom Chicken recipe with you! It only has 5 main ingredients and is a cinch to prepare! ~Danielle
Thank you Danielle for letting me share another one of my recipes with your readers here on Against All Grain!
I could never pass up a good chicken recipe especially one that is cooked with garlic. To me it is the most flavorful and aromatic element that makes anything and everything taste amazing.
I remember years ago, a dinner staple for me and my husband would consist of baked chicken breast pieces topped with canned cream of mushroom condensed soup, rice and some green beans on the side. Ever since switching over to eating Paleo, I've found a healthier way to recreate that to become a better dish.
The creamy and grain free garlic mushroom sauce spooned over baked chicken makes this dish a great week night comfort food that can be eaten with roasted green beans or steamed vegetables. Enjoy!
Jenny Castaneda lives in Southern California with her husband D and cat Mochi. She started a blog to share recipes with family and friends and also as a way to keep herself on track and connect with other fellow Paleo friends who have provided daily doses of inspiration and motivation along her journey towards a Paleo lifestyle. She enjoys traveling, photography, swinging kettlebells and obstacle course racing.
Connect with her on Facebook, Instagram and subscribe to her blog Paleo Foodie Kitchen to receive email notifications whenever new recipes are posted.
Melanie
Sounds yummy! Please consider adding the zip list recipe save option to make it super easy for us to keep your recipes and get a shopping list to make them! It offers so many more options than a “pin” offers! It would be awesome! Thanks! Check out out with Elana and Stacy and Matt
Shannon Feightner
When do the spices get incorporated Into this recipe? The instructions don’t mention it. can you clarify? Looks delish. Thanks!
Jenny @ Paleofoodiekitchen
Sorry looks like I missed adding that to the instructions. Season the chicken with spices before searing.
Sarah P
Are the seasonings added to the chicken before pan searing the chicken?
Stephanie
Looks great! Making this tonight. When are the seasonings added to the dish?
Lynne
Do you have a recipe for the bone broth? This sounds fab! Thx so much!
Carley J
Can I substitute chicken breasts in place of chicken thighs? I want to use what I have on hand. Thanks!
Jenny @ Paleofoodiekitchen
Yes breasts should be ok 🙂
Shama
Do you remove half the liquid for sauce before baking the chicken or after?
Jenny @ Paleofoodiekitchen
After baking 🙂 Basically you want to puree the liquid with the mushrooms and garlic as the final step to make gravy for the chicken
Lisa
The end dish came out great, but it took about 2 hours to cook in the oven rather than 15 minutes
Jenny @ Paleofoodiekitchen
Wow that took a long time. Did you sear the chicken first before popping it in the oven?
Becki Malloy
I really think the directions need to be tweaked on this post. I didn’t read the comments first and had no idea where to put the spices, so I just incorporated them into the broth. I think the chicken would have had more flavor if it was clear that I was supposed to season the chicken with the spices before searing. Also, 15 minute cook time is far from correct, especially if you follow the directions to sear the chicken for only 1-2 minutes per side. Perhaps if you seared the chicken for 5 mins per side you could get away with a 15-20 minute cook time. These were easily in the oven for 30-45 minutes.
Lia
I think what needs to be noted is that the chicken thighs were de-boned (or at least, that’s what I think). I just made it and it tastes great, but I had de-boned the thighs prior to searing them for 2 minutes. After taking them out of the oven for 15 minutes, they turned out great! Very juicy and the gravy was good as well.
I can see why there is confusion over the length of baking time if some people baked the chicken thighs whole with the bone still in-tact.
I replaced the ghee with butter and skipped out on the onion powder, sage, and cayenne pepper because I didn’t have them on hand. Still turned out good!
Sara
My chicken thighs had the bone, I only removed skin and it lasted about 30 min.
Sara
Had some chicken and I wanted a quick delicious meal since I’m getting tired of the same old pan fried chicken. I had chicken stop in freezer that had been there for a few months and had mushrooms so decided to try recipe. As with another viewer/follower I didn’t know what to do with spices and I didn’t have all of them so I just seasoned chicken with salt and pepper. I’m not strictly paleo so I used butter (real) seared chicken (a little more than 2min) maybe because of temperature. Did the rest but left the chicken in a Pyrex pie dish and added the sauce and was in the oven for 30 min. Delicious!!!!
Will definitely try again with other ingredients.
Thanks for recipe.
M.
This is DIVINE! Loved, loved, loved it! Note: I also didn’t know when to add the spices, so they were in the sauce for my dish, but it turned out delicious. Just enough heat and very savory! Will be making on the regular! Thanks for such a great dish, Jenny!
Star56
I think a good cook could work out the logistics. I did and also uses different spices. I improvise with recipes.
Steph
Delicious!
Erica
Oh thank you for this heavenly recipe. My picky toddler gobbled it up so that means it’s going into the rotation.