I was making chocolate pudding the other day and decided that it would make the perfect fudgsicle. I had just impulsively bought some cheap popsicle molds from Ikea (I'm buying these BPA free ones for future uses), so I gave it a try. These dark chocolate fudge pops turned out utterly decadent. They're smooth and velvety, and melt in your mouth like an ice cube on the hot summer pavement.
It seems everyone has some form of a fond memory of enjoying a frozen treat when the Summer days are at their hottest.
You must remember the infamous ice cream truck. The one that drove around the neighborhood daily during the Summer months blaring it's catchy tunes on repeat through blown speakers. A siren song of sorts, luring children from every park or playground for miles around. The truck, full of icy confections, would set off panic through the neighborhood children in fear of being too late and missing their chance the consume a bomb pop, push-pop or the creamy fudgsicle.
Have the ice cream trucks gone extinct? Since having my son two years ago, I always have an ear open for that identifying music, but have yet to hear it. Regardless, we wouldn't be able to partake in the consumption, so I try to make things like ice cream to fulfill the need from time to time.
I also plan to use this watermelon mint lemonade as a popsicle as well!
*For those that are egg-free, you can make these without the yolks but they won't be quite as creamy. You may also need to let them sit at room temperature for a little longer before they're soft enough to consume.
Shared with Slightly Indulgent Tuesdays
Carol L
These look perfect for a hot summer day! Thanks for the recipe! Yum 🙂
Sherrie
I really LOVE the color of these pop molds! Which brand are they? I would love to know….
Against All Grain
they’re from ikea. not bpa free so I don’t plan on using them again to be honest 🙂 I’m ordering some new ones from amazon as I mentioned in the post.
Sherrie
Ikea = awesome color, but not awesome for you or the planet.
Yeah, Tovolo is the way to go…already have my eye on them.
Thanks!
Dana
I have a set of Tupperware popsicle molds. They work awesomely (I have seen some plastic molds that are really poorly designed) and most of Tupperware’s products are BPA free.
Alaya
These look delicious. What brand of gelatin do you use?
pamela
Yeah, I’m ready to make these today! That is, I use Navitas Naturals raw cacao powder. How can I make the substitution for cacao powder, as unsweetned chocolate has additional fat in it?
Thanks!
Amanda
From a chocolate substitution site: “3 level tablespoons unsweetened cocoa and 1 tablespoon butter, margarine or shortening for every 1-ounce unsweetened baking chocolate.” I imagine you could use coconut oil instead of butter, which would be delicious.
Emily
Ice cream trucks still exist! We live in downtown Cincinnati and they drive by at least once a day. 🙂 These look delicious!
Alyssa mcclain
can you use almond milk in a recipe in place of coconut milk. Like for the fudge pops?
Against All Grain
I’m sure you can. Coconut milk is just so creamy so that’s why I use it for frozen desserts.
Caralyn @ glutenfreehappytummy
oh my gosh those look so delicious! cold and fudgy — perfect!
Trista
Made for myself and kids this weekend. Everyone enjoyed these! Love giving treats that are healthy.
Linda
Made these yesterday and ate one today. Loved ’em! I used Navitas Raw Cocoa Powder instead of the chocolate. I made a paste out of the warm coconut milk mixture and then used my immersion blender to mix the mixture all together. Had some trouble with the gelatin… It coagulated into a mess instead of softening, so I added some of the warm coconut milk mixture and stirred ad smooshed it until it dissolved. Immersion blender worked great for this recipe. I used about 1/4 cup maple syrup and thought they were sweet enough. Maybe I’m getting used to desserts that aren’t very sweet? My kids loved them too!
carol
Hello!! I was just wondering is the gelatin a must for this recipe to work?
Thank you!
Against All Grain
Hi Carol – I don’t think it’s required to make it work, but it definitely keeps the pops creamy and not icy. It will taste the same without it I’m sure. Did you know you can get fish gelatin? That’s what I use!
Jacqueline Riley
Omgggg these were so delicious. And perfect in this MIAMI heat. I just made these for a beach BBQ we had today along with my Banana Nut Ice Cream (sugar free, gluten free and almost fat free): https://www.secretsofafoodie.com/2012/05/banana-nut-ice-cream-for-two.html
Marci
I am making these now but when I added the vanilla to the geletin the geletin turned into a rubbery mass. Ideas??
Against All Grain
That’s what it’s supposed to do. It softens the crystals. Just whisk it in to the pudding and keep whisking until it has dissolved. If you still see lumps, run it through a strainer before freezing
Marci
Great, thank you!
Monique A
For me, these turned out to be more of a cold chocolate mousse or pudding that I ate out of the Popsicle mold instead of a fudgsicle (wasn’t really icy at all). I’m not really complaining though, because it tasted great. I’m assuming perhaps the gelatin I used caused it to be this way. Next time I will probably not use the gelatin. These taste delicious nevertheless.
Against All Grain
You may not have cooked the egg yolks long enough. Although, in the freezer I’m surprised they didn’t set up regardless. What kind of gelatin did you use?
Monique A
I will try again and cook the yolk mixture even more. I used Knox Gelatin, as it was the only one I could find in the store. It just seemed to make it between a jello and pudding texture. But still as I said, it tasted great anyways!
Rebecca
If you’re not dairy-free, can you make this with regular milk? Also is there a substitute for gelatin? My mom is allergic to it and reacts highly to it, but we love fudge pops!
Against All Grain
You should be able to use regular milk but I’ve never tried. Agar-agar powder is usually a good substitute for gelatin
Kat
My daughter LOVED these! I wish i could send you a picture of her smiling face with chocolate all over it. Just as an FYI I used the Tovolo molds and they are pretty big for a little kid + with the recipe it only made 3 pops because the molds are so big. I’m going to search for smaller molds.
Virginia
I bought little ones at TJMax for my grandson. BPA free, of course.
Carol
How long do these take to freeze? I made mine about 10 hours ago and ate one, it was like a solid gelatin pop, not frozen.
Tasted amazing but gel
Carol
I made these, kept them in the freezer for days and they still didn’t freeze. They were just really cold chocolate gelatin. What could have gone wrong? Still yummy but it wasn’t a fudgecicle for me.
Against All Grain
Did you use coconut milk from the carton? That’s the only thing I can think of because it had a lot of stabilizers and additives that could potentially keep it from freezing.
Julie M
They’re in the freezer as we speak, but they smell delicious! I ended up adding an avocado to the end of the recipe and threw it all in a blender to mix it together with the cacao powder I used in lieu of chocolate. I had a little extra after filling the molds and my daughter just ate it with a spoon and begged for more….so I think we have a winner 🙂
Cheryl
thanks for the recipe. Since being diagnosed as gluten and dairy intolerant, I’ve been making my own popsicles and ice cream. But my ice cream is always icy–this post gave me some good ideas for how to make it creamy like the dairy ice cream I make for my husband. and we will enjoy the fudgesicles immensely. I got free molds with my Ninja blander/food processor–so will use those.
May
This recipe was the perfect amount for filling the tray of 4 of these round pop molds. https://www.zokuhome.com/pages/round-pop-molds, with a silicone mold cover that doesn’t need to be run under hot water to release the molds, and is BPA-Free.
They are just now going into the freezer. It wasn’t until after I read the comments that I was sure whether or not I used the proper coconut milk – I used the “culinary” coconut milk in a can (not the beverage coconut milk), but accidentally used the Light version and not the full-fat which I had intended to use.
The mix tasted delicious from the bowl, I hope mine set up firm yet creamy! Will keep you posted!
Sarah Jane
Amazing. Having a heat wave where I am and these hit the spot!!! Super delicious.
Aimee
I made these yesterday and they didn’t actually freeze. They just became really cold chocolate gel. I used raw cows milk…..could that be what made it not freeze?? The flavor was good 🙂
Cathleen
Do you suppose you could do a recipe for Lime pops? I love your fudge ones, but I seem to crave Lime. Thank you!
Bridy Madill
Add lime zest instead of chocolate , that should be very tasty
Sheryl
Can I use something other than eggs , I’m allergic to them ?
Dee
do you think this would work with unsweetened almond milk, from the carton?
'Asa
What is the best brand of unsweetened chocolate to use? Seems like everything has soy lecithin in it!
Jenalyn
You might try a little avocado? But she said you could try without eggs but that it would be more Icy than creamy.