When you have had more than your fill of Thanksgiving dinner, sometimes you can feel as if there's no room left for dessert, which of course would be a cryin' shame. This light maple pumpkin custard is a sweet culmination to any Thanksgiving feast, but without the heaviness of a buttery crust. And, because you're saving calories by abstaining from the crust, feel no remorse when you make that dollop of coconut milk whipped cream a little larger than the photos.
Sweetened with pure maple syrup and speckled with hints of cinnamon and ginger, the maple pumpkin custard boasts all of the flavors of Fall. You can serve it warm if you prefer, but once it spends some time chilling, it becomes more firm even more robust in it's flavors. Pumpkin enthusiasts, do not fret as the season is coming to an end, this custard can be enjoyed right up into the Winter as well.
Also be sure to checkout my other holiday recipes in my book Celebrations!
Enjoy!
Shirley @ gfe
Oh, Danielle, I could sooo go for a cup of that custard right now … for breakfast! That’s my kind of healthy treat! 🙂
xo,
Shirley
Against All Grain
It’s a fantastic breakfast! I had some yesterday morning in fact! 🙂
Amanda
I’m making them for breakfast this morning!
Rachel Fenton
How much pumpkin pie spice would you use if replacing it for the individual spices?
Patricia
Hi, do you think this all work if you don’t have individual ramekins? Do you think you could bake it in one larger dish?
Against All Grain
Yes, it will probably just take about 15 more minutes.
Theresa @SCDgriddle
That looks devine, as your stuff usually does!
Theresa ~SCD Griddle
Against All Grain
Thanks Theresa! I hope you get to try it out!
Erin Collins
I just found your blog awhile ago and love it! We made these tonight and they were amazing! Thanks!
Against All Grain
Thank you so much, i’m glad you enjoyed them!
Yvette
This looks so good! I’m making this for breakfast tomorrow for the kids and myself. What a nice little treat 🙂
Danielle @ Fresh4Five
This looks so pretty. My kids love pumpkin mousse, I bet this warm cozy dessert would go over well with them. Beautiful photos as always.
k
when you substitute pumpkin pie spice, instead of the others; how much do you use?
Against All Grain
You may need to play around with the amount, but 2-3 tsp should be about the same.
Kathy
Thank you for sharing this wonderful recipe, it’s just like Pumpkin pie but with out the crust, I had no beautiful ramekins like yours , yours are absoultely outstanding so very pretty, so I poured mine in my deep glass pie pan baked it closer to 50 minutes “my oven is not super acturate” but it turned out GREAT! The cardamom made this extra special for me it’s one of my favorite spices. Thank you for this recipe and all your generousity, I appreciate it very much.
Against All Grain
This sounds great Kathy! And you are welcome, I am thrilled you love it!
Yasmine
Your website looks gorgeous and all your recipes look delicious. I don’t have any food allergies but I’ve been eating and cooking mostly Paleo for the past few months and I love it. I’ll certainly be stopping by A LOT to check out what you’re cooking:) Thanks!
Loretta | A Finn In The Kitchen
This looks tremendous! I love the idea of a custard….although I do love a buttery crust as well!
Rachel M
How many ramekins does this recipe make? I just bought 3 matching semi-large ramekins and want to try out this recipe in it. Beautiful picture too!
Tanna
Do you use canned coconut milk with this, or just the good old “carton” coconut milk?
Against All Grain
The cartons have a ton of additives. Always use a can or homemade.
Mark
When using coconut milk from a can, how do you dilute it? Or do you? Do you just stir it with a spoon to mix it and then use it straight or?
Have used SoDelicious unsweetened which I like, but not thrilled about careegenan, so was thinking about switching to a canned product.
Thanks!
Against All Grain
I don’t dilute it. The boxes do have a lot of additives so I always use the canned full fat kind. Stir it up if the cream has risen to top or scoop the cream off for whipped cream and use the water underneath in smoothies!
Rivkah
These look amazing! Whipping up a batch right now. How long will they keep? Thank you!
Pat
when a recipe calls for “coconut milk,” it means the canned, or can you use the stuff in the carton (sold in the refrigerated section with milk products)?
Against All Grain
Always use a can or fresh. The cartons in the refrigerated section have a ton of additives to make them thinner and more of a beverage.
Pat
good point…thanks for clarifying!
SmashinBeauty
good to know 🙂
Patricia
I used this as a filling for a paleo pumpkin pie to complete our Thanksgiving dinner, and it was delicious!! To cut the sugar a little, I swapped out 1/4 C maple syrup for more coconut milk blended with stevia. I also made a crushed cashew, cinnamon, and butter crust to go with it. YUM! Thank you for making our Thanksgiving a little bit better and healthier 🙂
Vikki
wonderful recipe. I had to use my corelle mugs for baking them in because I don’t have ramekins. It worked beautifully! They look magnificent and they taste fabulous as well. I used the honey instead of maple syrup, because I don’t have any and I’m not setting for less than 100% pure Canadian maple syrup. 🙂
Cindy
Just finished eating this awesome dessert. Didn’t have the whipped cream made, so I heated the left over coconut milk with the egg white mixed with a touch of honey and poured the cream on top. With and without the cream on top this was a hit with the family and helped with a pumpkin pie craving. Thanks!
SmashinBeauty
Can I substitute
1/2 cup coconut milk for Almond milk?
1/2 cup grade B maple syrup(honey) for Stevia? I don’t eat honey or anything like maple sirup
Against All Grain
You can sub the almond milk but I’m not sure about the stevia sub as I am not familiar with baking with it
Katherine
There is nothing I love more than pumpkin dessert! It’s the sole reason Fall is my favorite season. (Okay, that and Fall fashion.) This looks so delicious and thank you so much for sharing!
Liz
Is there a good non-dairy, non-coconut substitute for the coconut milk?
Against All Grain
It depends on the recipe but most of the time you can use almond milk.
Jennifer
This looks like a great recipe.
I make pumpkin custard in jars and put a lid on them, so kids can grab them for lunches or snacks at sports and such.
Debra
I made this today as I am trying out recipes for the holidays. I am so thankful I found your book and your blog. Everything I have made so far has been amazing!!! This recipe is perfect. My daughter is not a big fan of whipped cream so I mixed a few coconut crystals with some pumpkin pie spice and sprinkled on top out of the oven for an alternate topping. Thank you so much for the work you have done!
Marylynn
Oh My! I made these the other day and they never made it into the fridge to cool – warm, delicious & creamy.
JulieB
Being a baked custard, doesn’t the rimmed baking sheet, the custard cups are set in, need boiling water? Typical baked custards are baked in a water bath, aren’t they? Please forgive me if this has already been asked. I’m new. I added a little water to the rimmed baking sheet. Timer’s set. Here’s to happy pumpkin custard in 30 or so minutes!! Thank you for sharing your testimony and recipes!!!
Pamela Ann Pospichal
How much pumpkin pie spice?
Crystal
Do you have a suggestion for an egg replacement? I know that sounds silly for a custard, but thought I would ask.
Danielle
Unfortunately this recipe won’t work without eggs but I have a pumpkin pudding recipe on the blog that is egg free!
belinda
Really silly question – how do you make pumpkin puree? We cannot buy that in the shops and I cannot find instructions in your books